pumpkin full of hate

Saturday, September 16, 2006

and then there were three


We’re getting a new roommate. As it works out, said roommate is: 1, a she, and 2, twenty years old. When we placed the original ad, Girlfriend made it clear that she was hoping for a female (it was my account the e-mails went to, so weeding out the weak fell on my shoulders). I guess the thinking was that she can more comfortably trust me with some nubile coed, than she can trust some strange man living in our back room to keep from rooting through the laundry hamper to find soiled pairs of her underpants, for reasons best not explored.
As it turns out, the new roommate is very sweet. And yes, in answer to your next question, she is quite pretty. Not that this matter, or to the extent it does, not in the way you think. It’s not that I’m adverse to beautiful young women; in fact, I definitely fall on the ‘pro’ side of this issue. It’s just that I don’t suffer any Benny Hill delusions of sexual escapades. Aside from the boast factor (which I outgrew in my teens), there’s nothing automatically superior about an attractive woman in bed versus a plain one. I’ve never found a woman’s sexual talents or appetites to in any way be determined by her appearance, so the idea of an attractive woman in the vicinity, while certainly not a source of complaint, is, at the same time, no reason to start behaving like the keeper of a harem. I have nothing but the greatest admiration for the beauty of a youthful body, but realistically, any voyeuristic need to see a young woman nude can be easily met. There is quite a successful little industry that specializes in distributing images of nude and physically attractive girls, and it doesn’t take a great deal of effort to access more than enough naked flesh to sate my appetite.
Why the new roommate’s comeliness is a relief is for far more practical reasons than fulfilling some adolescent fantasy. The Girlfriend, who I’ve not yet settled on a appropriate nickname to call her by other than her title, is (not to brag) a very beautiful woman, looking a lot like a living anime character. While this may solicit ‘high fives’ from male readers (and perhaps any lesbians out there), this brings with it more burden than pleasure for her. Obviously, there is the afore mentioned threat of disappearing panties, but even more settling, is the constant target of hostility she is for other women. There is something dark and sick in our culture, where women who deem themselves as unattractive are given license to vent their self-loathing at women they consider more beautiful or thin. It’s socially acceptable behavior for a woman with a problem with her weight (or an imagined problem) to viciously attack thin women, making them pay for the suffering their failure to gain weight causes. I had never been that conscious of that kind of hostility until I started up with the Girlfriend, but after five years, I’d like to believe I’d developed a sensitivity to her plight.
And it is a plight. I know, there are those out there who balk at my choice of words, responding that they should be so lucky as to be a victimized skinny girl. But consider; the woman sensitive to her weight is the victim of some vaguely defined abstract social standard, a social standard they validate by exerting so much energy in defining their short-comings by. The Girlfriend (or any woman leaning toward the thin category), on the other hand, does not suffer the pages of fashion magazines or the beauty standards put forth on “Entertainment Tonight” and its kind…she doesn’t even read those magazines or watch those shows. What she does suffer is direct conflict with other women, face to face, not some remote electronic voice that can be turned off with the touch of a button.
A few years back, the Girlfriend was wrangled into going out for a bachelorette party being thrown for the bride to be of a family member. It was the usual tacky affair, all tiaras and squelling drunkenly. Except there was one woman, a friend of the bride, who could not contain the desire to express her hostility for the Girlfriend’s figure for more than five minutes. It started slowly, with an occasional declaration that, quote; “every time I see a skinny girl, I want to kick her”. No one gave her whatever agreements or reassurances so she repeated it, over and over again. Finally, crammed into the back of a taxi, she turned on the Girlfriend, telling her that while it was nothing personal, she felt a strong need to deliver a kick toward her. It’s not just that this sentiment is a disgusting, self-pitying expression of shallowness, it’s that none of the other women in the cab bothered to interfere of defend the girlfriend (who, aside from the bride, also had another sister in-law present). The message received that night was that women unhappy with their looks are entitled to vent hatred toward those women who are comfortable with their appearance, and that the victim of this bashing should accept in good stride, a small price to pay for being reasonably pretty.
Doesn’t this mind-set define you as handicapped, some sort of cripple that others should allow themselves to be the focus of your impotent rage, out of pity? Yes, those three girls on “Friends” were pretty skinny, but why the fuck are you watching garbage like that anyway? Why the fuck are you defining yourself by celebrities? What’s more, why are you comparing yourself to them solely in terms of their appearance, and not their wealth or success? You may retort with some convoluted feminist theory about the “beauty myth” and how society forces these standards on you, but you’re the one obsessed with your looks. And certainly don’t drag male sexuality into this. While pornography may impose narrow boundaries on beauty, sometimes, men are not pornography, and our tastes vary considerably farther than those addressed by the fashion world. Interestingly, the compulsive kicker was married…what does this say about her respect for her husband? His desire for her, his appreciation of her beauty, totally immaterial when compared to how she would fare as a contestant on “America’s Next Top Model”. This morbid, self-destructive fixation women have on their looks has nothing, I repeat nothing, to do with men. It’s some rotting left-over from before women had lives, before they could participate is society as a whole, and the only measure of self-worth they could obtain was in comparison with other women. Tragic…and disgusting.
So yes, our new roommate is young, talented, funny and beautiful, and we’re happy to have her move in and be a part of our little family. And I’m happy that what ever potential conflict that may eventually arise, it will be a result of apartment related issues, and not issues resulting in different sized waist, bust or thighs. I’m also happy that this post will be deleted long before she ever becomes aware that I keep a blog, rather than have her think the Girlfriend and I are a couple of total creeps.

P.S. In getting this article ready, I googled ‘menage a trois’ and ‘threesome’, to find some pictures to illustrate this with. Dear lord, the things I saw. I don’t want to traumatize you with the endless mess of limbs and penetrations I encountered. Okay, I can’t resist; here’s one link. Enjoy.


2 Comments:

At October 14, 2006 8:08 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Exception must be taken. Not all un-skinny girls are mean to thin women. Not all big and-or ugly women are catty or complain about attractive women. Sometimes it works in reverse - studies do show that good looking people of either sex get better jobs, promotions, grades, treatment in stores and the like. The classic image of a group of pretty girls picking on the fat girl is alive and well and can be found at a bar or an office or a high school near you, akin to the big muscle guy kicking sand in the face of the 98 lb. weakling.

This is not to imply that the situation you described with the kicker doesn't happen all the time. Of course it does. Maybe the pretty mean girls are not always as obvious about it (a "gentlewoman's agreement") or maybe we're so used to it that we don't notice it. Mean people are going to be mean whether they're a size 2 or 22, and it is not acceptable for either, but the sad fact is that it happens. Maybe your girlfriend isn't a miserable wench, and maybe she hasn't encountered or been part of a group that picks on anyone who is not as pretty or thin. If that's true, then she should be grateful and proud not to associate with it. Because it is disgusting, you are right, but it ain't going all one way.

 
At October 14, 2006 9:42 PM, Blogger Jason M Cutler said...

By no means did I intend to say that either all women who are not skinny are vicious bullies, or that thin women are gentle blossoms of understanding. Crappy people come in all shapes and sizes, male or female. I do, however, believe that there is a tendency amongst women to to denigrate their own looks, while singling out others who they feel possess the qualities they themselves lack. There's something deeply set in our general culture- that is amplified with women- that says it is better to be self-loathing than happy with who we are. When all is said and done, we are more comfortable with someone crying in a corner because they think themselves ugly, than we are with the spectacle of someone taking pleasure from their appearance.
Having known women of a variety of sizes, I can't help but see this as a crippling problem, regardless of their individual appearance. The number of women I have known who have exerted far too much energy over their weight is no greater than the number of slim women I've known, who suffer anxiety over the size of their breasts. This I guess I failed to mention in my original blog, that skinny women tend to be just as neurotic and self-loathing about their appearance as the non-skinny, just focused on the small bust-line endemic to their build. I don’t think the woman who mutilates her body by forcing sacks of chemicals under her skin is any less disturbing than the woman who endangers her health and sanity with starvation. What I had hoped to get across in my piece, that perhaps I will readdress in a more serious considered one soon (this was only my second posting) is that ANY of this self-torture or bullying steaming from poor body issue does nothing to improve either the current state of women or the happiness of the individual. This body mania is, in my humble opinion, a convenient sideshow distracting women from the reality of their second class status. Nothing benefits the continued marginalization of women better than keeping them at each others’ throats in an unending war between body types. And while there are certainly times when being skinny might give my girlfriend an upper hand (as there are times when it is a handicap), it doesn’t get her nearly as far as I can, simply because I’ve got a penis. That I myself am over-weight or less than hunky is immaterial- society values what I have to say and what I can contribute far more than if it came from a woman, regardless of her looks or measurements.
Anyway, thank you for your input; while many of the potentially offensive things I have written (or will write) are points that I stand firm behind, this is one that I fully admit I failed in communicating correctly. I hope that you continue to visit my silly little blog, and continue to point out when the arguments it offers are less than concrete.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home